Metal Roof Over Shingles Problems

Considering giving your home a durable upgrade with a metal roof? It’s a smart move for many homeowners, especially when thinking about longevity and efficiency. But, before you take the leap, it’s crucial to weigh the pros and cons, particularly when it comes to installing a metal roof over existing shingles. While it may seem like a straightforward solution, this approach can come with its own set of challenges.

From potential structural issues to warranty worries, laying a metal roof over shingles isn’t always as seamless as it appears. You’re likely looking for ways to save time and money on your roofing project, but it’s important to understand what could go wrong. This article will jump into the common problems homeowners face with this method, ensuring you’re well-informed before making your decision. Let’s explore what you need to consider to ensure your roof upgrade is a success, not a stress.

Key Takeaways

  • Weight and Structural Integrity: Metal roofs, though lighter than most traditional materials, still require an assessment of your home’s structural integrity to ensure it can support the added weight without modifications.
  • Adherence to Building Codes: It’s crucial to understand and comply with local building codes and standards regarding ventilation, the number of permissible roofing layers, and the use of underlayment, as failure to comply can void warranties and lead to legal and safety issues.
  • Ventilation and Moisture Management: Proper ventilation is paramount to prevent heat buildup and moisture trapping between the metal roof and existing shingles, reducing risks of mold, rot, and deterioration of roofing materials.
  • Professional Installation and Material Quality: Choosing the right materials and hiring experienced contractors for the installation are key factors in mitigating common installation issues, ensuring long-term durability, and adherence to building codes.
  • Routine Maintenance and Inspection: Regular inspection and maintenance of the metal roof can prevent minor issues from escalating, including checking for loose fasteners, ensuring gutters are clear, and avoiding direct walking on the roof to prevent damage.
  • Long-term Benefits Despite Initial Challenges: Despite the challenges associated with installing a metal roof over shingles, the long-term benefits of durability, energy efficiency, and lower maintenance make it a worthwhile investment for homeowners.

Assessing the Viability of Metal Roofs Over Shingles

When considering upgrading to a metal roof for its durability and efficiency, placing it directly over existing shingles is an option that might seem appealing. But, this method comes with specific challenges that you need to be aware of. Ensuring a successful roof upgrade requires understanding these potential issues and how to navigate building codes and standards.

Potential Issues With Weight Load

One of the first concerns you might have is the additional weight a metal roof places on your home’s structure when installed over shingles. Fortunately, metal roofs are generally lightweight, especially when compared to traditional roofing materials like asphalt shingles or tiles. A metal roof can weigh as little as 1.4 pounds per square foot, which is significantly lighter than the average tile roof that can weigh up to 10 pounds per square foot.

But, even with the relatively light weight of metal roofs, it’s crucial to evaluate the structural integrity of your home. Not all homes are built the same, and some older structures may not support the added weight without modifications. Consulting with a professional structural engineer can provide clarity. They’ll assess your home’s capacity to handle the additional load, ensuring safety and compliance with building codes.

Required Building Codes and Standards

Navigating the maze of building codes and standards is essential when installing a metal roof over shingles. These regulations are in place to ensure the safety, durability, and efficiency of your roofing project. Different municipalities may have varying requirements about the number of roofing layers permissible, ventilation standards, and the need for underlayment.

For instance, some areas limit the number of roofing layers to two, meaning if you already have two layers of shingles, adding a metal roof over them might not be an option without first removing a layer. Besides, adequate ventilation is crucial to prevent moisture buildup between the metal roof and shingle layer, which can lead to mold and rot.

Before proceeding with installation, contact your local building department. They’ll provide the most current codes and standards relevant to your area. This step is not just about ensuring your roof is up to code; it’s also about preserving the warranty on your metal roof. Failure to comply with these standards could void your warranty, leaving you unprotected against future issues.

Summarizing, while installing a metal roof over existing shingles offers benefits like durability and efficiency, it comes with considerations such as weight load and adherence to building codes. By addressing these factors proactively, you can ensure a smooth and successful roofing upgrade. Always consult with professionals and your local building department to make informed decisions that align with safety, regulatory, and warranty requirements.

Common Problems When Installing Metal Roof Over Shingles

When upgrading your home with a metal roof over existing shingles, knowing the common issues you might face is crucial. This approach has its benefits but can lead to specific challenges that, if not addressed, might affect your roof’s performance and longevity.

Inadequate Ventilation Concerns

Proper ventilation is paramount for any roofing system, and it becomes even more critical when installing a metal roof over shingles. Inadequate ventilation can lead to heat buildup in your attic. This not only causes your cooling costs to skyrocket during summer but also shortens the lifespan of your metal roof by causing the underlayment and shingles beneath to deteriorate more rapidly.

To avoid these issues, ensure that there’s a well-designed gap for air flow between the old shingles and your new metal roof. This might involve installing furring strips or a vented air gap. Consulting with a professional can help determine the best approach for your specific situation, ensuring that your roof has proper airflow to keep your home comfortable and your roofing materials in top condition.

Moisture Trapping and Leak Risks

When metal roofs are installed directly over shingles without adequate measures, moisture can become trapped between the layers. This moisture may not only lead to the growth of mold and mildew but also increase the risk of leaks, as it could eventually seep through to your home’s interior.

To combat moisture buildup, it’s essential to include a breathable synthetic underlayment between the metal roofing and the existing shingles. This layer acts as an additional barrier against moisture, allowing any trapped water vapor to escape, thereby minimizing the risk of leaks and water damage.

Structural Integrity and Longevity Issues

While metal roofs are notably lightweight, adding them on top of existing shingles without assessing the structural integrity of your home might lead to issues. The added weight, though minimal, can strain older structures or those not built to support multiple layers of roofing material. Besides, if the existing shingles are uneven or damaged, they can compromise the metal roof’s stability, leading to irregular wear patterns or even punctures.

Before proceeding with installation, have a professional evaluate your home’s ability to support a metal roof over shingles. This inspection should consider not just weight but also the condition of the existing roofing layer. In some cases, removal of the old shingles may be recommended to guarantee the longevity and performance of your new metal roof.

By understanding these common problems and actively taking steps to mitigate them, you can enjoy the benefits of your new metal roof without compromising on performance or safety. Always consult with roofing professionals who have experience with metal roofs over shingles to ensure that your upgrade adheres to local building codes and meets your long-term expectations.

Installation Challenges and Considerations

When you decide to install a metal roof over shingles, understanding the complexity and challenges of the task is crucial. This section aims at guiding you through the installation challenges and considerations to ensure a smooth, problem-free process.

The Importance of Proper Installation Techniques

Proper installation techniques cannot be overstated. Incorrect installation can lead to numerous issues, including leaks, improper drainage, and eventually, a reduction in the lifespan of your new metal roof. The first step is ensuring that your roof’s structure can support the additional weight of a metal roof overlaid on existing shingles. Consulting with a structural engineer can provide peace of mind and prevent potential structural issues.

Ventilation is another critical aspect. A well-ventilated roof helps prevent moisture accumulation, which can lead to mold, rot, and other moisture-related issues. Utilizing breathable underlayment between the shingles and the metal roofing is an effective strategy to enhance ventilation.

Finally, correct fastening of the metal panels is essential. The panels must be securely attached to withstand high winds and prevent water ingress. Each manufacturer may have specific installation guidelines, so following these closely will help ensure the integrity of your roof.

Selecting the Right Materials and Contractors

The selection of materials and contractors plays a pivotal role in the success of your metal roofing project. When choosing materials, consider factors such as the local climate, the existing roof’s condition, and the aesthetic appeal. Opt for high-quality materials that come with a warranty for added security.

Finding the right contractor is equally important. Look for experienced professionals with a solid track record of installing metal roofs over shingles. Ask for references, review their previous work, and ensure they are licensed and insured. A reputable contractor will not only provide valuable insights tailored to your specific situation but also ensure the project complies with local building codes.

To conclude, focusing to proper installation techniques and carefully selecting the right materials and contractors, you can overcome the challenges associated with installing a metal roof over shingles. This proactive approach will help ensure your roof’s longevity, functionality, and aesthetic appeal, providing lasting protection for your home.

Advantages of Metal Roofs Despite the Problems

While the decision to install a metal roof over shingles presents its set of challenges, it’s crucial to understand the significant benefits that make this roofing option attractive. Beyond the hurdles lie advantages like energy efficiency and durability that not only enhance your home’s functionality but can also contribute to long-term savings.

Energy Efficiency Benefits

Metal roofs stand out for their exceptional energy efficiency. This trait stems from the material’s ability to reflect solar radiant heat rather than absorb it, which can reduce cooling costs by 10-25%. During hot summer months, a metal roof can be a game-changer for your energy bills. The reflective property of metal roofs means your air conditioning doesn’t have to work overtime, maintaining a comfortable temperature inside your home with less energy.

Also, some metal roofing materials are treated with special pigmented coatings that enhance their reflective capabilities. This means even on days with peak sunlight, your home stays cooler without an additional load on your HVAC system. It’s a sustainable choice that not only benefits your wallet but also the environment by reducing your carbon footprint.

Durability and Maintenance Prospects

Another compelling reason to consider metal roofing is its remarkable durability and minimal maintenance requirements. Metal roofs are known to last between 40 to 70 years, significantly longer than traditional asphalt shingle roofs that last about 20 years. This longevity stems from metal’s resistance to decay, mold, and pests, as well as its ability to withstand high winds, hail, and fire.

In terms of maintenance, metal roofs require surprisingly little to stay in good condition. They don’t rot, split, crack, or warp, making them virtually maintenance-free. This doesn’t mean they’re indestructible, but the usual concerns like frequent leaks or the need for replacement tiles that plague other roofing materials are significantly reduced. Periodic inspections to ensure no damage or obstructions can help your metal roof last even longer, making it a wise investment for the future.

The upfront cost of installing a metal roof over shingles may seem daunting at first, but when you consider the reduced energy bills, longevity, and minimal maintenance needs, it’s clear why many homeowners find this option appealing. By choosing a metal roof, you’re not just covering your house; you’re making a long-term investment in its value, comfort, and sustainability.

Addressing Problems Proactively

Installing a metal roof over existing shingles poses unique challenges but can provide substantial benefits with the right approach. Understanding how to proactively address potential issues ensures the longevity and efficiency of your metal roof. Let’s jump into strategies for mitigating common concerns and tips for regular maintenance and inspection.

Strategies for Mitigating Common Issues

To alleviate common problems when installing a metal roof over shingles, a proactive approach is essential. Here’s how you can mitigate these issues effectively:

  • Ensure Proper Ventilation: Adequate attic ventilation prevents heat buildup and condensation, which may lead to rot or mold under your new metal roof. If the existing shingle roof had ventilation issues, address these before installing the metal roof.
  • Check for Structural Integrity: Before adding a metal roof atop shingles, assess the structural integrity of your existing roof and home. The additional weight, although often minimal with metal roofs, requires verification that your structure can support it without compromising safety or longevity.
  • Adhere to Building Codes: Familiarize yourself with local building codes. Some areas may restrict multiple layers of roofing materials. Ensuring compliance avoids legal hassles and ensures that your roof installation meets safety standards.
  • Use a Certified Contractor: Opt for contractors with proven experience in metal roofing installations, particularly over existing shingles. Their expertise can prevent improper installation, which is a leading cause of issues down the road.

Regular Maintenance and Inspection Tips

Even with a metal roof’s durability and longevity, regular maintenance and inspection are key to avoiding potential problems. Here are some tips to keep your metal roof in top condition:

  • Routine Inspections: Conduct bi-annual inspections of your metal roof to catch and address minor issues before they escalate. Look for signs of wear, such as loose fasteners or seals, rust formation, and any damage or deformations.
  • Keep Gutters Clean: Ensure gutters and downspouts are clear of debris to prevent water accumulation. Water backup can lead to rusting or damage to the metal panels and potentially affect the underlying shingles.
  • Trim Overhanging Branches: Reduce the risk of physical damage by trimming branches that hang over your roof. Besides preventing scratches or dents, this step also minimizes the accumulation of leaves and natural debris that may retain moisture against the roof surface.
  • Avoid Walking on the Roof: Minimize walking on your metal roof to prevent dents or damage. If roof access is necessary, use proper walking pads or hire professionals who know how to navigate without causing harm.

By implementing these strategies and maintenance tips, you’ll not only extend the life of your metal roof but also maximize the benefits offered by this durable roofing option. Addressing potential issues proactively and maintaining regular upkeep will keep your metal roof over shingles performing efficiently for years to come.


Tackling the installation of a metal roof over shingles might seem daunting but armed with the right knowledge and a proactive approach, you can navigate through the challenges smoothly. Remember, ensuring your home’s structure can support the additional weight and adhering to local building codes are crucial steps not to be overlooked. Hiring a certified contractor can also make a significant difference in the project’s success. With regular maintenance and a keen eye on ventilation and structural integrity, your metal roof will serve you well for years to come. So here’s to making an well-informed choice that not only enhances your home’s efficiency and durability but also contributes to a greener planet.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I install a metal roof over existing shingles?

Yes, you can install a metal roof over existing shingles, but you must check the structural integrity of your home to ensure it can support the additional weight. Also, compliance with local building codes and proper ventilation must be addressed.

What are the benefits of installing a metal roof over shingles?

Metal roofs offer energy efficiency due to their reflective properties, reducing cooling costs in warm seasons. They are also more durable than traditional shingle roofs, often lasting 40-70 years with proper maintenance.

What considerations should be taken into account before installing a metal roof over shingles?

Before proceeding, consider the weight load your house can support, adherence to local building codes, ensuring proper ventilation to prevent moisture buildup, and the roof’s structural integrity.

How can common issues be addressed when installing a metal roof over shingles?

Common issues can be addressed by ensuring proper ventilation to avoid moisture problems, checking structural integrity to support the metal roof, complying with building codes, and hiring certified contractors for installation.

What maintenance tips are recommended for a metal roof installed over shingles?

To maintain a metal roof, conduct regular inspections, keep gutters clean, trim branches that may come into contact with the roof, and avoid walking on the roof to prevent damage.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *